The Best Rejection I Ever Had
On Saturday, I got a "rejection" letter.
I had submitted the text of one of my favorite blog entries -- God and the Spin Doctor -- to my favorite radio show -- "This American Life" for consideration.
By the way, if you have never experienced This American Life, I will just state here, for the record, that I think it is the smartest, funniest, most moving, thought-provoking, and amazing piece of broadcast media that I have listened to or looked at. Ever. If you don't use the link above to find out more about it, I will consider that you have missed out in life. It's broadcast on our local NPR station (KUOW - Seattle) at 7 pm every Friday evening, and 11 am every Saturday morning. You can also listen to their archives online on your computer at the link above.
I have had a lingering desire to write a piece for this show ever since I first heard it coming out of my radio back in the 90s. Finally, I decided to do something that I had not done for nearly eight years -- I made a literary submission.
I did so with none of the expectation that I used to have as a youngster. I am now a "sadder-but-wiser" girl. I knew perfectly well that their submissions editor is probably deluged with fantastic material on a weekly basis. I knew perfectly well that my piece would probably be given no more than a cursory glance. I was prepared for either no response, or a form-letter rejection notice.
What I got instead was the most delightful rejection letter I had ever received in my life -- perfectly in step with the tone and energy that makes me love this program:
"Dear Carol,
Thank you for your recent submission to This American Life. I'm writing to say that the material you send (sic) isn't quite right for the show.
Please know that we reject a lot of material that's perfectly good work that simply doesn't fit the constraints of a radio show, or the idiosyncratic needs of This American Life. Even frequent contributors often find themselves reading letters remarkably similar to the one you now hold in your hands.
Best of luck to you in the future,
And thanks very much fro (sic) your interest in the show.
Yours,
Chris Ladd"
And now, I will break into song -- " . . .do let me down easy, yeah, yeah -- do let me down easy . . . . "
Somehow, Chris managed to make rejection an enjoyable experience for me. Now that's finesse. That's style. That's humanity.
I have been the recipient of other, less humane rejections -- in the course of relationship, to be certain, but also as a writer/poet/performer ("Dear sir or madam . . . "), as a budding young actress in the 70's (where you knew it was time to leave the stage when the audition agent simply said "thank! you" without looking up from his desk), and, more recently, as a psychic/channel/teacher when someone asks what I do "for a living", I tell them, and their eyes glaze over as they make a hasty retreat to . . . somewhere . . . anywhere but here -- and then pretend that they have never met me at some point in the future (and they never again ask me what I "do").
I've come to the point where there is no longer any real sting in these kinds of "rejection". However, I never imagined that the experience could be fun.
Maybe the misspellings in the letter are purposeful -- meant to give me the sense that I am getting a real letter -- just for me -- but even if that were the case -- even if this is actually a form letter that no one took any real time thinking about -- even if the seemingly real ball-point pen signature is simply the product of a really good printer -- I don't care. Even if all these cynical, self-protective thoughts that I entertain were true -- at least the folks at TAL tried to give me a sense of person-hood in their approach.
It's possible that my experience of this letter is related to some actual maturation process on my part. That is possible . . . . I suppose . . . . maybe.
It's also possible that it's been so long since I actually got a rejection letter that it's kind of a novelty (my last literary submission was in 1997 -- six of the ten poems I sent actually got accepted to an anthology . . . that never went to print -- but that's another story entirely).
It's also possible that this radio show actually makes an effort to treat the people who submit material to them feel like human beings. That's possible too.
I feel glad.
I used to harbor dreams of someday being "discovered". I don't know if this was a product of living my formative years when "old hollywood" still existed (cut to scene: home-spun but spunky young girl is plucked out of the chorus line by a whiskery director: "Hey, who's that gal there? She certainly can hoof it!"), or if this is simply the pervasive substance that allows closet writers/painters/actors to keep writing/painting/acting.
In fact, I was "discovered" twice in this incarnation. The first time, in a Judy-Garland-Star-Is-Born the early happy scenes kind of way, the second, in a Judy-Garland-Star-Is-Born the later slightly sleazy unhappy scenes kind of way.
"Being Discovered" Incident #1: I am closing the final show of my college acting career. (1978) I have been playing"Peter" in Peter Pan. I will graduate from college in a week, and I have no idea what I will do after that. I have the vague thought that I would like to be a professional actress -- I have schooled for this for four years -- but I have done so in a small Kansas town (about 17,000), and the thought of high-tailing it off to LA or New York seems -- well -- simply unimaginable.
High School seems eternal at 17, and college seemed eternal at 22. It just could not be ending, therefore, there was no reason to plan for any future. The future was now.
I return to the dressing room in the basement of the theater after the final curtain comes down, after I have been flying around (no shit, really) on wires for two weeks, belting out the big show-stopping numbers, dueling Captain Hook, saving Wendy and the lost boys.
I'm not exactly depressed. There's a cast party to attend, and my college graduation in a week, where I will grasp the diploma that seems to be the holy grail my parents have been wanting me to find.
I walk into the dressing room -- it's a chaos of quick-changed and discarded costumes, blow-dryers, open make-up containers, and weirdly, no people -- the usual gaggle of costume and makeup mistresses, the Indian Princess, Wendy, Nana, and Wendy's mom (the only females in the cast, basically, who were all there for curtain call) are nowhere to be seen.
At my makeup station, there's a big, huge, overwhelming bouquet of roses. I walk up to see who they came from. I'm thinking my mom and dad, but this seems rather effusive of them, and besides, they sent me flowers on opening night. (We are just not a two-bouquet kind of family.)
As I bend over to read the card, a voice from the door says: "So, Carol -- want to be in a show?"
At the door of the dressing room is my friend Steven, who graduated from this same theater department two years ago and went off to New York to seek his fame and fortune as an actor.
Long story short, he has moved back to Kansas, formed a song and dance company attached to the very large and very profitable catering company owned by his lover's family, and wants me to show up -- as soon as I've finished school -- like, the next week -- to join his company in Wichita, Kansas (a really big city in Kansas).
I do. For most of the following Summer, I ride around in his boyfriend's Silver Shadow Rolls Royce to hoof it for rich and not-so-rich folks who are gobbling down the catering company's infamous rib-eye steaks at various and sundry events. I wear a hand-tailored tuxedo with eyelash-glitter vest (which I still have), and a slinky spaghetti-strap dress (which I still have), stiletto heels (which I still have), and false-fingernails, and lots of make-up, and I somehow talk them out of making me wear false eyelashes, convincing that my own downy lashes will be adequate. (Check out my eyelashes sometime -- really!) I get to belt out all the Judy Garland tunes (You Made Me Love You, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, Zing Went the Strings of My Heart) because Steven likes the way I do them, and I'm the slightest, shortest member of the troupe, so I evoke that Dorothy-ish quality. (I realize that, for some of you, this version of me may be hard to imagine, but I have the photos to prove it.)
Even at 22, I knew this was a one-of-a-kind experience. I even suspect that I held some sort of "this is too good to last" cynicism in my young heart, even then. Perhaps I created what happened next.
Everything was fine until Steven's beau's grandmother (grand matriarch and founder/owner of the catering company) figured out that Steven and her grandson were, perhaps, more than just "friends" -- maybe even more than just "boy" "friends" -- that perhaps, these two words, so innocuous when taken separately, had been joined in an obscene and perverted way.
That was the end of the company. Grandma cut the very long purse strings and the troupe was called in at our next scheduled rehearsal date and informed that, if we wished, we would all be offered jobs in the catering company as "help". (A job which I accepted for a short time. A very short time. I left this job to become a gas-station attendant at a Fina station managed by a dyke I knew. Imagine my mother's horror!)
So ended my first illustrious experience with being "discovered". It lasted two and a half months.
"Being Discovered" Incident #2: Fast forward 15 years to 1993. I have been performing as a lesbian stand-up comic and musician since 1988. (Again, no shit -- check Roz Warren's "Revolutionary Laughter" -- a book about women stand-ups -- I'm right in there, sandwiched alphabetically between Carrie Snow and Judy Tenuta.)
I go down to California. The plan is to perform at a couple of women's festivals, and in transit, to do a slot at "Josie's Juice Joint", a club in the Castro in San Francisco. I have been helped to this gig by Karen Ripley, a great person and comic who I'd met in Portland, where I lived at the time.
I am following Tom Ammiano and Marga Gomez. I'm nervous.
I'm a teeny-weeny baby comic. These are people with names and off-broadway shows and they look at me like I'm a bug. I go out on stage for my 15 minutes. I do my schtick. I sing the song that even the gay-pride organization in Portland asked me not to sing, because it was just too -- oh, I don't know -- too -- lesbian. The crowd is cheering and crowing. They're dying laughing. They love it. I walk off the stage and Marga Gomez turns to me and says, cooly, but not without respect: "You killed."
So, I am invited to a "special" party that night. The kind of party not everyone gets invited to, but that many people want to get invited to.
Some producers from Olivia music are there (if you're not a lesbian, you probably won't even know what Olivia music is, and if you are, and you do know, you're probably dating yourself by admitting it). I am personally introduced to these muckity-mucks. I am pleased.
One of the producers says to me -- "So," (she doesn't actually say "kid", but I can sense it hanging in the air -- it just wouldn't be politically correct to call me "kid") "So . . . Carol? Would you be interested in coming on our Boat?"
At that time, Olivia music has been doing these "women's (1980's code word for lesbian) cruises" for the past few years. It was a big deal to perform on Olivia Cruises. They still exist, by the way, but now, since we're so much more enlightened, they actually use the word "lesbian".
"Yes, sure I'd be interested!" I drooled.
"Great. Well, there is this one thing -- you know that song you sang tonight -- the one that has the line about "filling up and spilling over". . . .?"
A light bulb comes on. This "one thing" is that I am quoting, verbatim, a song by an Olivia artist. A big star in their stable. The big star in their stable.
"Yeah . . . ?" I say, cautiously.
"Well, we'd probably have to change that a little."
I explain to the woman I'm talking to that this line is a major factor in what makes the song funny, which seems relatively unimportant to her.
I'm starting to have that "uh-oh" feeling when she says:
"Oh yeah, and we'd like it if you didn't say 'fuck' so much."
So ended my second experience with "being discovered". It lasted approximately two and a half hours.
I didn't exactly turn her down. I think that the look on my face was enough to initiate her hasty retreat to somewhere . . . you know -- anywhere but here -- and to pretend that she hadn't been introduced to me for the rest of the party.
So, I figure I've been discovered already -- not once, but twice. This helped a lot when I was submitting an unsolicited manuscript to a radio show that I adore. I didn't really expect a third discovery -- or even a nod, really.
But the response I received from TAL -- quite frankly, I found it breath-taking.
This rejection letter has inspired me to do at least two things:
- If I have to turn someone down in the future -- even a panhandler -- I will strive to do it with the most creative act of grace and personal acknowledgement that I can.
- I will rethink my idea that the desire to "be discovered" is solely the province of artists and performers. I'm beginning to think that pretty much everyone is hoping to be "discovered" -- that all of us may be longing to have someone look at our home-spun edges and see the genius and capability just below the surface. I will be looking for that -- in everyone -- with the eye of a whiskery producer in the future -- who knows what treasures I might find?








